Hongkong’s Regulations for Operational Resilience

Hongkong’s Regulations for Operational Resilience

Vinod Menon
Head – Customer Success
Vinod Menon
Head – Customer Success

On 22nd December, 2021 HKMA (Hong Kong Monetary Authority) came up with a Supervisory Policy Manual for Operational Resilience to provide Authorized Institutions (AI) with guidance on the general principles which they are expected to consider when developing their operational resilience framework.

When is an AI said to be Operationally Resilient?

An AI is said to be operationally resilient if it can satisfy the following

  • Identify and mitigate risks that may threaten the delivery of critical operations.
  • Continue to deliver critical operations when disruptions occur, including under severe but plausible scenarios and disruptions must not exceed its tolerance for disruption.
  • Resume normal operations promptly after disruptions occur
  • Learn from disruptions or close-misses to continually improve

 

What is critical operation and its tolerance for disruption?

Critical operation refers to activities, processes and services performed by the AI, as well as the supporting assets (including people, technology, information and facilities) necessary for the delivery of such activities and services, which if disrupted, could pose material risks to the viability of AI itself or impact the role of AI within Hong Kong’s financial system.

A tolerance for disruption is defined as maximum level of disruption to a critical operation that an AI can accept and is in practice the point after which further disruption would pose a threat to the viability of the AI or impact its role within the Hong Kong financial system.  Situations that would result in significant disruptions, and while unlikely to occur, remain probable refers to severe but plausible scenarios.

 

Components of Operational Resilience Framework

It is important to note that developing operational resilience is an ongoing process. The process will not always be linear. An AI should actively apply what it learns from its implementation of the framework and the management of actual incidents to continuously improve the effectiveness of the framework.

The following components constitutes an operational resilience framework

  1. Active participation of Board and senior management
  2. Identify critical operations
  3. Identify and set tolerance level for disruptions of critical operations
  4. identify severe by plausible scenarios which could cause disruption to critical operations
  5. Mapping the interdependencies and interconnections to deliver the critical operations
  6. Identify risks and preparation for risk management to manage the identified risks
  7. Scenario testing to assess if an AI is able to deliver critical operations through disruption and in severe but plausible scenario
  8. Incident management program to effectively respond to and manage disruptions to critical operations delivery

 

  1. Active participation of Board and senior management

The board should take an active role in establishing a broad understanding of the AI ​​operational resilience framework. It should clearly communicate the objectives of the framework to all stakeholders, including staff, intra-group entities and third parties. Regular training on the AI’s operational resilience framework should be provided to these parties to reinforce their understanding.

 

  1. Identify Critical Operations

Some of the criteria`s to be considered to identifying the critical operations are

  1. Impact on customers and personnel
  2. Impact on financial reputation
  3. Legal and regulatory implications
  4. Role played by the AI in the financial system

 

  1. Identify and set tolerance levels

A tolerance for disruption should be set for every critical operation. It must include at least one time-based metric, but can also include a combination of other quantitative (eg. volume or value of transactions) and qualitative metrics (e.g. reputational or legal implications).

AIs must be aware that their operational capabilities may vary during different business cycles or as a result of seasonal factors and should be considered while setting tolerance.

 

  1. Identify severe but plausible scenarios

AIs should identify a range of scenarios of different natures, severity and duration relevant to its business and risk profile. Examples of scenarios AIs may consider include, but are not limited to, pandemics, natural disasters, and failures or disruptions at a third party or within the third party’s supply chain.

When identifying the scenarios, AIs should refer to previous incidents or near misses within the institution or across financial sectors, as well as in other sectors or jurisdictions, or any situations that could result in significant disruptions given the changing operational landscape.

 

  1. Mapping interconnectedness and interdependencies

(a) The appropriate functions within an AI should identify and document:

  • The people, processes, technology, information, facilities; and
  •  The interconnections and interdependencies among these factors that are necessary for the AI to deliver its critical operations. When considering
  •  An AI should also include those interconnections and interdependencies that depend on third parties and intragroup arrangements.

(b) The approach and level of granularity of mapping should be sufficient to enable the AI to identify vulnerabilities and facilitate the testing of the AI’s ability to deliver critical operations through disruptions.

(c) The mapping documentation should be prepared in a way that it should also be usable by all relevant parties in the event of disruptions.

(d) AIs are expected to update their mapping documentation on a regular basis, but no less than annually or following any material changes to their operations.

 

  1. Preparation for and managing risks

(a) AIs should be prepared to manage all risks with potential to affect critical operations delivery. As a given critical operation may face a number of risks, AIs should leverage different risk management frameworks, as appropriate, to offer holistic and comprehensive support to the critical operation.

(b) The HKMA expects that AIs should, at a minimum, take into consideration the following risk management components

  • Operational Risk Management
  • Business Continuity planning and testing
  • Third Party dependency management
  • An ICT (Information & Communication Technology) policy including cyber security

 

  1. Scenario Testing

(a) AIs should conduct regular testing of their operational resilience framework to ensure that they are able to continue delivering their critical operations through disruptions, including under severe but plausible scenarios.

(b) When considering the testing requirement, AIs should take into account the following:

  • The testing exercises should include realistic assumptions, and should encompass the AI’s interconnections and interdependencies, including those through relationships with intragroup entities and third parties.
  • The frequency of testing should be determined based on a variety of factors, including the potential impact of a disruption, how many critical operations an AI has, and whether the operating environment has materially changed.
  • Different types of testing (e.g. paper-based, simulations or live-systems testing) serve different purposes and AIs should deploy the most appropriate type of testing based on the nature or needs of the specific testing exercise.
  • AIs should deploy staff with appropriate expertise to conduct the testing. The testing approach should dictate the type of staff involved, including their seniority, qualifications as well as the function
  • AIs should consider how they may leverage the testing exercises to enhance their staff’s operational resilience awareness and readiness to operate during disruptions, thereby improving their ability to effectively adapt and respond to different types of disruptive events.

(c) Where practicable, AIs may leverage on existing testing arrangements, including the arrangements devised for business continuity planning purposes, to fulfill the testing requirement relating to operational resilience. An AI should be able to demonstrate how an existing testing exercise enables it to achieve the specific objectives of scenario testing for operational resilience purposes.

(d) After each testing exercise, an AI should prepare a formal testing report to record any gaps or weaknesses identified, as well as document the remedial actions planned. The reports should be reviewed by the AI’s senior management.

 

  1. Incident Management Program

The incident management programme should capture the full life-cycle of any incidents and involve:

  • Classification of the severity of an accident according to predefined criteria. This should enable the AI to prioritise and allocate resources to respond to an incident.
  • Incident response and recovery procedures. These should be reviewed, tested and updated on a regular basis. Their connection to the AI’s business continuity, disaster recovery and other associated management plans and procedures should also be clearly documented.
  • Communication plans for reporting incidents to both internal and external stakeholders. Communication should take place during the incident (e.g. to provide performance metrics), and after, including to convey analysis of lessons learned.
  • Root cause analysis of incidents to help with the prevention or minimisation of recurrence.
  • The incident management programme should be supported by an inventory of internal and third party resources to enable prompt incident response and recovery.

 

Implementation of Operational Resilience requirement

 Application

The requirements contained in this module apply to all AIs. Locally incorporated AIs should endeavour to implement the guidance of this module with respect to their subsidiaries and overseas operations, and for overseas incorporated AIs with respect to their operations in Hong Kong.

Timeline

By 1 year after the date upon which the final module is issued, the HKMA expects an AI to have:

(a) Develop its operational resilience framework; and

(b) Determine the timeline by when it will  implement the operational resilience framework and become operationally resilient.

(c) HKMA has decided to allow AIs up to 2 years to become operationally resilient.

After this point in time, an AI will be expected to have fully implemented its operational resilience framework, including to have conducted scenario testing, and be able to satisfy the requirements.

 

 

 

 

Recent Blog’s

Share

Explore more

Process Visualization for Operational Risk & Resilience
Operational Resilience

Growing Importance of Process Visualisation in Operational Risk & Resilience Management

Embarking on a journey through the realms of Process Visualization, Operational Risk, and Operational Resilience. let us understand the Growing Importance of Process Visualization in …

DORA's Role in Enhancing ICT Risk Management
Operational Resilience

Fortifying Digital Frontiers: DORA’s Role in Enhancing ICT Risk Management

In the complex world of contemporary finance, where new digital innovations occur at a dizzying rate and new cyber dangers appear at every turn, the …

ICT Risk Management: Outline of DORA Article 5-16 - Gieom
Operational Resilience

The ICT Risk Management Revolution: An Outline of DORA Articles 5-16

Due to continuous digital advancements, the financial sector is seeing significant hurdles in handling and reducing information and communication technology (ICT) risks. The Digital Operational …

Regulatory Expectations Resilience Testing Dora
Compliance Assurance

DORA – Digital Operational Resilience Act – 10 Expectations From Resilience Testing by the Regulator

DORA expects financial entities to establish, maintain, and review a sound and comprehensive digital operational resilience testing program as an integral part of the ICT …

Dora Navigating ICT Business Continuity
Compliance Assurance

Navigating Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA): Unveiling the ICT Business Continuity Management Landscape

As part of the regulatory framework, financial entities must establish an ICT Risk Management framework, with specific requirements tailored for smaller financial entities outlined in …

Switch to Digital SOPS
SOP Digitization

Embracing Digital SOPs: Why Your Company Should Make the Switch!

Digital Standard Operating Procedure (SOPs) are documents having set of instructions which are maintained in an electronic way. Every company requires SOPs to circulate it …

Optimizing Operational Risk
Risk Management

Optimizing Operational Risk: A Strategic Edge for Your Competitive Success

The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision defines operational risk as the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, systems, and people. Operational …

Unlocking Excellence Adhering to DORA
Compliance Assurance

Unlocking Excellence: The Significance of Adhering to Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA)

In our digital era, reliance on information and communication technology (ICT) continues to grow. The heightened digitization and interconnectivity, however, escalate the risks associated with …

Dora Compliance
Compliance Assurance

Top Reasons to Adopt Dora Compliance in a Tech-Driven Financial World

THE DIGITAL OPERATIONAL RESILIENCE ACT (DORA): The European Commission, European Council Presidency, and European Parliament introduced DORA in 2020 to establish a structure for financial …

Digital Identity

Top 4 Reasons How Banks and Financial Organisations Benefit from Strong Policy Management Systems

WHAT IS POLICY MANAGEMENT AND WHY IS IT IMPORTANT: Policy management is a crucial procedure in financial institutions involving the development, execution, and revision of internal …

Organizational Culture and Employee Engagement Through SOP Digitization
SOP Digitization

Enhancement of Organizational Culture and Employee Engagement Through SOP Digitization

Importance Of Sop Digitization: Within business operations, Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) have traditionally served as the foundation for enhancing efficiency, ensuring uniformity, and maintaining quality …

The Role Of Technology In Automating Policy Compliance
Compliance Assurance

The Role Of Technology In Automating Policy Compliance

WHAT IS COMPLIANCE? Compliance is a multifaceted process that ensures an organization follows applicable laws, regulations, and internal norms. Understanding and interpreting critical legal requirements …

Process Mapping – The What, Why and How?
Operational Resilience

Process Mapping – The What, Why and How?

What is Process Mapping? Let us break down the words. Process means “a series of actions you do for a particular purpose that produce an …

The Role of Process Mapping in Change Management
Operational Resilience

The Role of Process Mapping in Change Management

Change is constant in the fast-paced world of business. Companies must frequently adjust operations to respond to market developments, technology advancements, or internal reorganisation. Process …

Overview of the Australian Operational Resilience Regulatory Guidelines
Operational Resilience

Overview of the Australian Operational Resilience Regulatory Guidelines

The objective of this Prudential Standard CPS 230 is to establish and uphold operational resilience for APRA (Australian Prudential Regulation Authority) regulated entities. Such entities …

How Financial Institutions can benefit from Incident Management Solution?
Incident Management

How Financial Institutions can benefit from Incident Management Solution?

Financial institutions, such as banks, insurance companies, and investment firms, face various challenges in their daily operations. They have to deal with complex regulations, high …

From Spreadsheets to Success: Advantages of Operational Risk Management Software for Financial Organizations
Risk Management

From Spreadsheets to Success: Advantages of Operational Risk Management Software for Financial Organizations

Many financial organizations still rely on spreadsheets to manage their operational risk data. While spreadsheet is a powerful and versatile tool, it has some limitations …

Building Resilience: The Crucial Role of Policy Management Solutions in Compliance with the Digital Operational Resilience Act(DORA)
Operational Resilience

Policy Management Solutions: Your Key to DORA Compliance

A policy management solution is of utmost importance from a Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) regulation perspective. The DORA regulation aims to ensure the operational …

SOP Digitization Solution
SOP Digitization

How to Choose the Right SOP Digitization Solution?

Standard operating procedures (SOPs) are essential for any business that wants to ensure quality, consistency and compliance in its processes. However, managing SOPs can be …

Why is it Important for the Financial Institution to Digitize its Standard Operating Procedure?
SOP Digitization

Why is it Important for the Financial Institution to Digitize its Standard Operating Procedure?

The financial sector is undergoing a rapid transformation due to the emergence of new technologies, changing customer expectations, and increasing regulatory demands. In this context, …

6 Simple Steps for Implementing an Operational Resilience Framework
Operational Resilience

6 Simple Steps for Implementing an Operational Resilience Framework

On March 29, 2021, the Bank of England (BoE), Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA), and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) jointly issued policy and supervisory statements to …

Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) – A Brief Overview
Operational Resilience

Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) – A Brief Overview

The use of information and technology is essential in the modern era as it supports complex systems used for daily activities. It plays a critical …

Operational Resilience Program – Steps to Conduct a Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA)
Operational Resilience

Operational Resilience Program – Steps to Conduct a Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA)

Basel defines Operational Resilience as a bank`s ability to deliver critical operations even at times of disruption. This would mean that the bank should have …

Impact Tolerance – Setting Impact Tolerance is a Vital Step to Build and Enhance Operational Resilience of an Organisation
Operational Resilience

Impact Tolerance – Setting Impact Tolerance is a Vital Step to Build and Enhance Operational Resilience of an Organisation.

Impact Tolerance is quantifying the level of disruption, a critical business service can accommodate or absorb, before such disruption creates a significant impact or harm …

Improve your Organisation’s Decision Making and Response Mechanism through an Integrated Risk & Resilience Approach
Risk Management

Improve your Organisation’s Decision Making and Response Mechanism through an Integrated Risk & Resilience Approach

During last twelve to twenty four months we have all experienced extraordinary uncertainty primarily due to natural calamity, COVID-19 pandemic, unstable global economy,  political differences …

Operational Resilience Programme – Digitize your BIA (Business Impact Analysis) – An Important Step
Operational Resilience

Operational Resilience Programme – Digitize your BIA (Business Impact Analysis) – An Important Step

Let’s first try and understand what is a BIA? Business Impact Analysis is a methodology which allows to predict the impact of disruption on your …

Synopsis of the Operational Resilience guideline of MAS- Monetary Authority of Singapore
Operational Resilience

Synopsis of the Operational Resilience guideline of MAS- Monetary Authority of Singapore

Operational disruptions, if not recovered speedily, may compromise the ability of financial institutions (“FIs”) to meet their business obligations, resulting in financial and reputational damage, …

The What and Why of BPMN – Business Process Model and Notation
BPMN

The What and Why of BPMN – Business Process Model and Notation

The Business Process Model Notation (BPMN) is a graphical representation for specifying business processes in a business process model. The objective of BPMN is to …

Key Highlights of APRA`s Discussion Paper on Strengthening Operational Risk Management
Risk Management

Key Highlights of APRA`s Discussion Paper on Strengthening Operational Risk Management

Events of recent years like COVID-19, cyber-attacks, flood and storms etc. has reinforced the importance of managing and responding to operational risks. To ensure that …

An Integrated Risk and Resilience Framework – A Better Approach to Manage Uncertainty
Risk Management

An Integrated Risk and Resilience Framework – A Better Approach to Manage Uncertainty

Businesses across the globe have, in the last couple of years, seen exceptional uncertainty due to political tensions, economic turmoil, COVID-19 pandemic and others.   Markets …

The Seven Steps to Implementing an Effective Risk Management Process
Risk Management

The Seven Steps to Implementing an Effective Risk Management Process

Risk Management Process is a methodology by which risks are formally identified, measured and treated to ensure that risk is avoided, transferred or mitigated. As …

Simple steps to Automate and Standardise your Risk & Control Self Assessment (RCSA)
Risk Management

Simple steps to Automate and Standardise your Risk & Control Self Assessment (RCSA)

Risk and Control Self Assessment process is a widely accepted methodology used by banks, financial companies, insurance companies and others to identify and assess the …

Key Risk Indicators -A Powerful Tool to Anticipate Your Risk Within the Enterprise
Risk Management

Key Risk Indicators -A Powerful Tool to Anticipate Your Risk Within the Enterprise

In simple terms, Key Risk Indicator (KRI) is a metric used to measure the level of exposure to risk. These are indicators that denote the …

Irelands’ Financial Service Sector Guidance on Operational Resilience
Operational Resilience

Irelands’ Financial Service Sector Guidance on Operational Resilience

The Central Bank of Ireland`s objective of this guidance is to communicate to industry how to prepare for, respond to and recover and learn from …

New Operational Resilience Regulation
Operational Resilience

New Operational Resilience Regulation for Financial Institutions in United States (USA)

The Federal Reserve, the Central Bank of the United States in August 2021 has released a paper intended to help community banks assess threats when …

Process Mapping Operational Resilience Framework
Operational Resilience

Process Mapping is an important step in building an Operational Resilience Framework

The Covid -19 pandemic has clearly shown two trends within firms: The intensified use of technology and Operations can be managed through digital work force …

What is Game-Based Employee Onboarding?
Game-based Learning

What is Game-Based Employee Onboarding? Tips and tricks to implement the right gamification strategy

Learning begins with joining. Effective Onboarding contributes to a newbie commencing with confidence, feeling supported, and acclimatizing much sooner. Conversely, employees who spend weeks and …

Strategies for Improving Banks Operating Efficiency
Digital Transformation

Strategies for Improving Banks’ Operating Efficiency

Banks occupy a place of pride because of its structure of undivided attention and contemporary functions. They have come an extended way from merely performing …

Get started with Digital Identity Verification
Digital Identity

Get started with Digital Identity Verification

In a growing interconnected digital economy, identity verification of an individual’s real-world identity against their digital one has become ever critical in fraud detection. The …

Importance of Operational Resilience
Operational Resilience

Growing Importance of Operational Resilience in the Digital Era

Operational Resilience assumes that things will go wrong, and it will force organizations to plan on how to recover from the disruption. It is a …

Why are organizations jumping onto the AI-enabled Identity verification bandwagon?
Digital Identity

Why are organizations jumping onto the AI-enabled Identity verification bandwagon?

Who has not experienced being asked to show some kind of government ID, be it to receive your courier, or check into a hotel, or …

What is Identity Proofing?
Digital Identity

What is Identity Proofing?

As per the Digital Identity Guidelines published by NIST, a US agency, Identity Proofing is verifying the claimed identity of an applicant by authenticating the …

New Amendment to KYC Regulation by RBI
Digital Identity

New Amendment to KYC Regulation by RBI – 10th May, 2021

In Jan 2020, Reserve Bank of India amended the KYC norms allowing banks and other lending institutions to use Video based Customer Identification Process (VCIP) …

Successful Execution of a Digital Transformation Project
Digital Transformation

5 Steps to a Successful Execution of a Digital Transformation Project

Digital Transformation is bringing about a radical shift in the way you run your business, deliver services or manage your customers. The objective of digital …